I had read online that Heinz had a low sugar ketchup that was hfcs free. I was thinking about trying it despite the fake sweetener, but when I was at the store I found Heinz Organic Ketchup. It doesn't have hfcs or fake sweetener. I tried it today and it tasted great. It's not as thick as the original version, but I'm guessing it's the hfcs that gives it the thickness so that's probably a good thing.
Happy BBQing!
Meghan